Lei Ye

Archive — Design studio

Typological Mutation

A heterotopic antique market for Liwan, drawn from the logic of the Chinese garden

2016 Fall · Liwan, Guangzhou

Typological Mutation

Typological mutation is the organising principle of this studio project — a response to the dense, layered context of the Liwan district in Guangzhou, where the classic comb-like texture of southern Chinese architecture grinds against fast modern urbanisation. The district's antique market becomes the site: a hybrid of many cultures and periods, read as a heterotopia, and rebuilt as a set of collaged boxes on the plan of a traditional Chinese garden.

Typological mutation is the organising principle of this project — a response to the dense, layered context of the Liwan district in Guangzhou. Liwan carries the classic texture of southern Chinese architecture, a fabric laid out like the teeth of a comb. And like much of the city, it has urbanised fast, until modern development now grinds against the historic zones it grew out of.

Its antique market is where that friction becomes legible — a hybrid of cultures from many periods, a heterotopia in which different contexts and different times are all present at once, inside a single building. The market is itself a hybrid, drawn straight from the complexity of Liwan.

Liwan collaged — Canton Tower, pagodas, shophouses and the antique trade
Liwan collaged — Canton Tower, pagodas, shophouses and the antique trade

To work with that, the prototypes of the antique market are studied closely, and the layout of the traditional Chinese garden is brought onto the site — a way to knit together the river along its edge, the dense neighbourhood, and the modern high-rises, and to open up the varied spaces a heterotopia needs.

A typology of antique markets — Panjiayuan (Beijing), Confucian Temple (Nanjing), Jinan Temple (Shanghai), Xiguan (Guangzhou)
A typology of antique markets — Panjiayuan (Beijing), Confucian Temple (Nanjing), Jinan Temple (Shanghai), Xiguan (Guangzhou)
The site — plaza, water and neighbourhood, mapped
The site — plaza, water and neighbourhood, mapped

Layout of the traditional Chinese garden

After studying the site, a set of functional prototypes is drawn from it — open-air theatre, bank, market, street shop, alley, and hybrid buildings — taken both from the history of the area and from how it works today.

Six prototypes against a Song scroll — open-air theatre, bank, antique market, street shop, alley, hybrid (酒肆 · 戲臺 · 典當鋪 · 納涼 · 趕集)
Six prototypes against a Song scroll — open-air theatre, bank, antique market, street shop, alley, hybrid (酒肆 · 戲臺 · 典當鋪 · 納涼 · 趕集)
Plans of three classical gardens — the Humble Administrator's, Yiyuan and Liuyuan
Plans of three classical gardens — the Humble Administrator's, Yiyuan and Liuyuan

The architectural form of the Chinese garden is a good translation of regularity and irregularity — a distinction that matters a great deal when you are arranging a set of boxes against a context this complex. Following the garden's rules, the boxes — the pavilion, the street shop, and the rest — are connected in ways that are at once ordered and disordered.

From box to programme — pavilion, gallery, trade centre, street shop, evaluation centre, free market
From box to programme — pavilion, gallery, trade centre, street shop, evaluation centre, free market

Collage boxes

The project sets out to explore how an architecture grounded in historical, typological and social context can act as a link, and a representation, for a new urban community in an area defined by divergence.

Massing in six moves — from site to eight disordered boxes with courtyards
Massing in six moves — from site to eight disordered boxes with courtyards

By setting the market apart from its context, the design creates a confrontation — and, through it, a strengthened identity: the antique market in dialogue with the city, architecturally and socially. The aim is a dialectical architecture, one that belongs to the community of the city and yet insists on its own individuality, holding the tension between the city's differences. To build a new market inside the existing city, in the field of tension between centre and periphery, is to try to redefine the architecture of the city through a reinvestment in form — a rediscovery and reinterpretation of the city's defining features, through articulated boundaries and definite architectural forms.

Floor plan — the boxes set into the grain of the city
Floor plan — the boxes set into the grain of the city
The boxes, inside — street shop, gallery, trade centre, free market, evaluation centre, pavilion
The boxes, inside — street shop, gallery, trade centre, free market, evaluation centre, pavilion
Study model — the white boxes set into the dark city
Study model — the white boxes set into the dark city

A strategy for context

The approach to context is not a direct reflection of it, but an attempt to build an idiom of abstract, definite architectural forms. The forms are drawn from the existing urban structure — not from Liwan's iconic landmarks, but from its abstract elements: the sequence of open and closed spaces, the rhythm of walls and columns, the continuous run of facades with their repeated openings and ornament.

The market in the street — a low hall against the high-rises
The market in the street — a low hall against the high-rises

Liwan's character becomes the ground for a morphological transformation of the site, and for a new arena — one that, for all its autonomy of expression, keeps the essence of the city, and acts as a link between its different parts.

Inside — a glazed court with a lotus pool, cranes and painted clouds
Inside — a glazed court with a lotus pool, cranes and painted clouds
A room between worlds — pavilion, mountains and the antique trade
A room between worlds — pavilion, mountains and the antique trade
Year2016 Fall
LocationLiwan, Guangzhou
ProgramDesign studio
StatusAcademic
Chungking MansionsBack to archiveThe Cloister